Skip to main content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Updated 4 November 2026

What Property Buyers Need to Know About the Contract for Sale #17: How do I handle disputes with the seller?

Explore CM Law’s buyer questions about the contract for sale and property contract review services.

A dispute with a property seller needs a response matched to the contract and the stage of the purchase. The priority is to establish the facts, preserve any time-sensitive rights and avoid creating a default while seeking a solution. Clear advice early can help you distinguish a negotiable problem from a legal right to withdraw.

What should I do when a dispute with the seller arises?

Contact your solicitor promptly, identify the immediate deadline and preserve the relevant evidence. Explain what happened, when you discovered it and what outcome you want. Avoid sending a termination notice, withholding money or agreeing to a variation before the contract and available remedies have been assessed against the actual facts.

My practical advice is to separate the problem from the proposed response. A missing inclusion, inaccurate statement and inability to give vacant possession raise different issues. Send the signed contract, correspondence, advertisements and any inspection report together so the advice starts with reliable information.

Why does it matter whether contracts have been exchanged?

Before exchange, a buyer will usually have greater scope to negotiate terms or decide not to proceed, although any separate obligations still need checking. After exchange, an enforceable contract can impose significant commitments. Settlement creates further changes, and some rights must be exercised before completion rather than saved for later.

NSW Government guidance explains contracts and deposits. Tell your solicitor exactly what has been signed and exchanged, whether a cooling-off period applies, and the scheduled settlement date. An accepted offer or paid holding deposit should not be confused with completed exchange.

Does the seller have to disclose every defect?

No general rule requires every private seller to list every physical defect. NSW law prescribes particular contract documents and warranties, while other obligations can arise from contractual promises, misleading statements or specific legislation. The required legal disclosures do not replace a suitable building inspection or property-specific enquiries before exchange.

The Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2022 governs prescribed documents and warranties. Inspection reports have their own scope and exclusions. A problem discovered later must be connected to an applicable obligation; the discovery alone does not prove that the seller broke the law.

Can I use cooling-off rights instead of proving a breach?

If an applicable cooling-off period remains available, it may provide a separate way to withdraw without proving seller wrongdoing. Most ordinary residential purchases have five business days, while qualifying off-the-plan contracts have ten. Exceptions and valid waivers matter, and prescribed written notice must be served within the applicable time.

Ask your solicitor to confirm the actual deadline and financial consequence under the Conveyancing Act. Auction purchases and certain other transactions have no cooling-off period. A complaint or ongoing negotiation does not itself extend the period or count as a valid rescission notice.

What if a required document is missing or a warranty is breached?

Missing prescribed attachments and breaches of prescribed warranties have distinct statutory tests and deadlines. A required missing document can support rescission in circumstances different from an undisclosed warranty breach. Your solicitor should check applicability, any exception, the information already disclosed and the steps needed to exercise a right before completion.

Sections 21–23 of the Regulation contain the relevant remedies. Do not assume every missing report is a prescribed attachment or that every building defect breaches a warranty. The contract, legislation and evidence must be read together before notice is served.

When can misleading property statements support a claim?

A misleading-conduct claim depends on the statement or overall conduct, who was responsible, the legal framework and the loss alleged. The Australian Consumer Law applies to conduct in trade or commerce; an ordinary private sale does not automatically meet that requirement. Agents and commercial sellers require separate assessment from private vendors.

NSW guidance explains agents’ misrepresentation duties, including prescribed material facts. Other contractual or misrepresentation remedies may still be relevant. Save the exact advertisement or answer, identify its author and record how it affected your decision; a later disagreement is not enough by itself.

What evidence will help establish the problem?

Keep the complete contract and attachments, dated advertisements, messages, emails, photographs and inspection records. Record the sequence of events while it is fresh. Where condition, boundaries or approval status is disputed, an appropriately qualified expert may be needed to explain the issue, its significance and when it likely existed.

Preserve original files rather than edited screenshots alone. Obtain advice before destructive testing or substantial repairs, while taking reasonable steps to limit further damage. Pre-purchase inspection guidance helps distinguish visible findings from matters requiring specialist investigation or further records.

Can I refuse to settle if I find a problem?

Not automatically. The issue may justify a particular contractual or statutory remedy without allowing you to delay or terminate. Refusing to settle without a valid basis can expose you to default consequences. Ask your solicitor to assess the defect, relevant terms, notice requirements and any proposed extension before taking that step.

A final inspection is useful for checking condition and inclusions against the contractual arrangements. Notify your solicitor immediately about damage, missing items or occupants. Do not assume you can deduct a repair estimate from the settlement money without agreement or legal entitlement.

What if the seller cannot complete on the settlement date?

The contract determines the completion obligations and consequences of delay. A missed ordinary settlement date does not necessarily permit immediate termination; a valid notice making time essential may be needed. The reason for delay, existing notices and each party’s readiness to perform can affect the available options and risks.

Keep your lender and solicitor informed and document accommodation or other costs. Any extension should address its terms clearly. A claim for compensation requires a legal basis and proof; the seller is not automatically liable for every inconvenience or expense caused by delay.

Should we try negotiation or mediation?

Often, a carefully framed proposal can resolve the practical problem without litigation. Possible terms include a repair obligation, price adjustment, agreed extension or release from the contract. Mediation can assist where direct negotiations stall, but it does not impose a settlement or automatically preserve rights while statutory or contractual deadlines run.

The Supreme Court describes mediation. Agree any deadline extension separately and record settlement terms clearly, including payments, releases and implementation. Confidential negotiations still need legal oversight, particularly where an urgent injunction or valid notice may be necessary to protect your position.

What remedies might a court provide?

Depending on the proven claim, a court may award damages, grant rescission, order specific performance or provide other appropriate relief. These remedies have different requirements and are not interchangeable. Specific performance is discretionary, and compensation requires a proper connection between the wrong and recoverable loss, not merely an unhappy purchase.

Ask what evidence, expert work and costs each option requires, and whether the other party can satisfy a judgment. Consider reasonable steps to reduce avoidable loss. Consumer law remedies must be assessed under the relevant provisions rather than assumed from general advertising guidance.

Can NCAT or a regulator resolve my land sale dispute?

Do not assume a dispute about buying land is an NCAT consumer claim simply because the amount falls below a monetary limit. Jurisdiction depends on the claim and remedy. Courts, tribunals and regulators have different powers; a complaint about an agent is not the same as obtaining orders against the seller.

NCAT describes its consumer jurisdiction in relation to goods and services. A separate building, strata or professional-services issue may require another pathway. The ACCC does not resolve individual real estate disputes. Obtain advice about the correct forum before filing or paying fees.

What does the Butcher case show about disputed sales information?

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Limited [2004] HCA 60 concerned buyers who alleged that a waterfront property brochure misrepresented the boundary near a swimming pool. Their claim against the selling agent failed. The decision shows why identifying who made or adopted a representation matters when assessing a property dispute.

The brochure reproduced a survey diagram obtained through the vendor’s contract documents and contained qualifications about information from others. Considering the whole transaction, the High Court majority concluded that the agent had passed on the information without adopting the alleged representation. The buyers’ appeal was dismissed. This was an agent-liability decision under the predecessor consumer legislation, not a rule that every disclaimer defeats a claim or every seller is protected. Buyers should verify material boundaries and development assumptions independently, and obtain advice about each potential defendant’s actual conduct.

What should I consider before pursuing litigation?

Compare the strength of the claim, the remedy realistically available, likely legal and expert costs, time, enforceability and your practical objectives. Winning does not necessarily recover every expense, and an unsuccessful claim may carry adverse costs. Obtain a staged estimate and review settlement options as better evidence becomes available.

Act promptly because notice requirements and limitation periods differ. If settlement has already occurred, ask which rights remain and what further evidence is needed. Do not rely on an assumed universal deadline, a promised success percentage or the original purchase price as proof of loss.

How can CM Lawyers help with a seller dispute?

CM Lawyers can review your contract, disclosure documents and evidence, identify urgent deadlines and explain the available options. We can assist with correspondence, negotiation and appropriate dispute proceedings. Early advice helps you choose a response that addresses the problem while understanding the obligations that continue under the sale contract.

Arrange a property contract review on 02 9557 9000 or lawyers@cmlaw.com.au, or contact us. Our office is Level 3, Unit 3.07, 18–30 Faversham Street, Marrickville NSW 2204.

General information only, current at 4 November 2026. Obtain advice about your contract and circumstances.

Key resources

CM Lawyers  ·  Level 3, Unit 3.07, 18–30 Faversham Street, Marrickville NSW 2204  ·  (02) 9557 9000  ·  lawyers@cmlaw.com.au