Updated 4 November 2026
Off the Plan Potential Problem #14: Resale Difficulties
Back to the off-the-plan property guide
Reselling an off-the-plan property in NSW can be possible, but finding another buyer does not automatically release you from your purchase contract. Before advertising or signing another agreement, check the permitted transaction, required consent and how both deals will be funded. A workable exit needs legal documents, realistic pricing and enough time to complete the necessary steps.
Why can an off-the-plan property be difficult to resell?
A resale before completion depends on more than buyer demand. The original contract may restrict dealings, the finished property cannot yet be fully inspected, and finance may remain uncertain. You may also compete with the developer’s unsold apartments. These factors can affect price, timing and the structure of any proposed sale.
The NSW off-the-plan guide recommends asking about resale rights before signing. If your circumstances have already changed, start with the contract you hold. An agent’s confidence that another buyer can be found does not resolve the contractual requirements.
What is the difference between a sub-sale and an assignment?
A sub-sale creates a separate sale agreement between you and another buyer, while your original purchase remains relevant. An assignment transfers contractual rights. A novation substitutes contractual arrangements with the necessary parties’ agreement. These mechanisms have different consequences, so the documents must match the transaction you actually intend to complete.
Calling an arrangement a nomination does not settle its legal or tax effect. Your lawyer should identify who must pay the original price, who receives title and what happens if the replacement buyer fails to perform.
Does finding a replacement buyer release me from liability?
No. Assignment alone does not transfer your contractual obligations or release you from them. An effective novation or another agreed release may achieve that result, but its terms matter. Obtain written advice confirming whether you remain responsible for settlement, earlier breaches, guarantees or other liabilities after the new arrangements take effect.
A replacement buyer’s promise to reimburse you is different from the developer releasing you. If that buyer defaults, you may still have to complete your purchase and then pursue a separate claim against them. Check any continuing guarantees expressly.
Do I need the developer’s consent before selling?
Check the exact contract. It may require prior written consent to an assignment, nomination, sub-sale or marketing campaign, with conditions about the agent, price or replacement buyer. Do not assume consent is automatic, that silence means approval, or that every restriction is unenforceable because your circumstances have changed.
Have your lawyer submit the required information and request a clear written response. If consent is refused or delayed, assess the clause and available remedies before proceeding. Any obligation to act reasonably must be established from the contract and applicable law.
How should I assess a realistic resale price?
Compare recent completed sales of genuinely similar properties and competing stock, including the developer’s remaining apartments. Adjust for floor level, size, parking, outlook, completion risk and incentives. Your original purchase price records what you agreed to pay; it does not establish what another buyer will pay now.
Ask the agent to explain the evidence behind the estimate and distinguish advertised prices from achieved sales. Developer incentives can affect comparisons. Obtain an independent valuation where the difference between the likely price and your settlement obligations is significant.
What happens if the lender’s valuation is lower?
A valuation below the contract price can reduce the amount a lender is prepared to advance and increase the cash required at settlement. Earlier conditional approval does not guarantee final funding. This risk can affect both you and your proposed buyer, so confirm finance arrangements before relying on the resale.
The Australian Government’s Your Home guidance explains the need for a final valuation and lending decision. A finance shortfall does not itself rewrite the purchase contract. Ask your lender about available options and have your lawyer assess the consequences if settlement cannot proceed.
How do I calculate the actual cost of exiting?
Prepare a written estimate of net proceeds after the original purchase obligations, selling expenses and relevant taxes. Include legal work, agent’s commission, marketing, finance costs and any agreed consent costs. Compare a prompt sale with completing and holding the property, using realistic timelines and a contingency for delays.
Separate costs payable now from those arising only after completion, such as ownership outgoings. Where a loan funds settlement, account for its discharge without counting the purchase price twice. A higher resale price can still leave a loss after transaction costs.
Could changing the buyer create additional transfer duty?
Yes. Revenue NSW explains that novations, nominations and assignments can involve separate dutiable transactions. The amount and availability of relief depend on the structure and facts. Do not assume that replacing a name, cancelling and reissuing a contract, or making a direct transfer to another buyer avoids duty.
Obtain duty advice before signing the new documents. Any eligible off-the-plan duty deferral also needs review because an assignment can bring payment forward. The parties’ private agreement about who pays does not determine the statutory liability.
Can GST or income tax affect the resale?
Yes. The ATO’s residential property guidance warns that selling off-the-plan contractual rights before settlement may constitute an enterprise, require GST registration and attract GST. The income tax treatment also needs review. Do not assume that every resale produces a discounted capital gain or that a loss is immediately deductible.
A commercial transaction undertaken for profit can be treated differently from realising a capital investment. Give your tax adviser the original purpose, contracts, payments and proposed sale terms. Confirm the treatment before agreeing a price, including whether any GST is included.
Can the resale deposit fund my original settlement?
Do not rely on that without checking the legal and payment arrangements. A deposit held by a stakeholder may not be available for your use. The original purchase and resale also need compatible completion dates and funding. A buyer’s signed contract is not the same as cleared settlement money.
The NSW off-the-plan disclosure regime protects deposits under covered contracts until settlement. Have your lawyer map when each payment can be released and coordinate with the lenders. Allow for the consequences if one transaction is delayed or fails.
What if I cannot find a buyer before settlement?
Unless you have a valid exit right or an agreed variation, the original contract may still require you to settle. Failure can expose you to termination, loss of deposit and further claims, depending on the contract and circumstances. Do not treat forfeiting the deposit as a guaranteed limit on liability.
Speak to your lawyer and lender before the due date. A negotiated extension, release or alternative arrangement may be possible, but the developer is not automatically obliged to agree. Record any agreement formally, including costs, deadlines and whether existing defaults are waived.
What does a real NSW resale dispute show?
In Fuentes v Bondi Beachside Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 531, purchasers entered a sub-sale of an off-the-plan Bondi Beach apartment without the vendor’s required written consent. The court found a breach, but held that the particular breach did not justify termination and ordered the original contract to be completed.
The purchasers remained ready and willing to pay the original price. The court treated the transaction as a sub-sale, not an assignment or novation. The vendor had not proved loss from the consent breach and received $20 in nominal damages.
The decision turned on that contract and those facts. It does not authorise buyers to ignore consent clauses or promise the same result under a different contract. Obtain advice promptly if the developer issues a notice asserting default or termination.
Can delays or changed plans provide an exit right?
Sometimes, but a resale problem alone is not a cancellation right. Applicable off-the-plan laws and the contract may provide remedies for qualifying disclosure failures, materially prejudicial changes or specified delays. Each remedy has conditions and deadlines. Obtain advice promptly when a notice arrives or a potentially relevant change becomes known.
The Registrar General’s guidance explains protections for changes to material particulars and sunset clauses. Short response periods can apply. A sunset date is not a general right to walk away whenever the market falls, and vendor rescission under a sunset clause is specifically restricted.
How is resale after settlement different?
After settlement, you generally sell the completed property through a new sale contract, with the usual title, disclosure and mortgage-discharge requirements. Buyers can inspect the finished dwelling and investigate strata records. Completion may resolve some uncertainty, but it does not guarantee demand, a higher price or recovery of your costs.
Have the sale contract and required documents prepared before advertising. Review any continuing restrictions, tenancy arrangements and outstanding defects with your lawyer. The NSW selling guide explains the ordinary sale process; your funding and holding costs still need careful assessment.
How can CM Lawyers help with an off-the-plan resale?
CM Lawyers can review the purchase contract, identify consent requirements and continuing liabilities, and advise on the documents needed for a proposed resale or negotiated release. Send us the original agreement, developer correspondence and proposed transaction details before committing to another buyer, particularly where the settlement deadline is approaching.
For off-the-plan property advice, contact CM Lawyers on (02) 9557 9000 or email lawyers@cmlaw.com.au. Include the settlement date, the finance position and whether a resale agreement has already been signed.
This article provides general information, not legal, financial or tax advice. The court case is real and depends on its facts and contract. Obtain advice about your transaction before signing, cancelling or delaying settlement.
Key resources
NSW Registrar General — Off-the-plan disclosure and protections.
Australian Government Solicitor — Novation and assignment of contracts.
Australian Government Your Home — Buying a house off the plan.
Australian Taxation Office — Residential property and GST guidance.
Australian Taxation Office — TR 92/3 on isolated profit-making transactions.
NSW Supreme Court — Fuentes v Bondi Beachside Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 531.
CM Lawyers — Property contract reviews and fees — Have the contract reviewed before you sign or bid.
