Skip to main content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Updated 4 November 2026

Contract for Sales - Seller’s Most Asked Questions # 34. What are the risks of selling a property ‘as is’?

Selling a NSW property “as is” can avoid undertaking negotiated repairs before settlement, but it is not a complete legal shield. The contract, required disclosures and statements made during marketing still matter. The practical risks include price negotiations, disputes about condition and delays if buyers discover information that changes their assessment.

What does selling a property “as is” actually mean?

Usually, it means the buyer accepts the property’s existing condition, subject to the contract and applicable law. It does not automatically remove every seller obligation or require the buyer to accept anything that happens later. The wording must identify the condition being accepted and any repairs or other promises that remain.

The Law Society’s selling guide explains that property is generally sold in its existing state unless the contract provides otherwise. Specify inclusions and exclusions, such as appliances or equipment, and identify any agreed repairs. An advertisement saying “as is” is not a substitute for properly drafted contract terms. Do not remove fixtures merely because the property needs work.

Must a seller disclose every known physical defect?

There is no single rule requiring every private seller to list every physical defect. NSW’s prescribed disclosure duties, contractual promises and rules about misleading conduct must be considered separately. Fraudulent concealment can also create liability. An “as is” clause should never be treated as permission to give false answers or conceal problems.

Tell your solicitor about leaks, structural concerns, pest reports, unapproved alterations, disputes and notices, even if you are unsure whether disclosure is required. They can distinguish physical condition from title problems and statutory warranties, then advise on the contract. A buyer’s opportunity to inspect does not automatically excuse a misleading statement. Give the agent consistent, accurate instructions and correct earlier information when necessary.

What documents and warranties still apply in NSW?

An “as is” sale remains subject to NSW vendor disclosure requirements. Section 52A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 requires prescribed documents and implies statutory terms and warranties. Common documents include title information, drainage diagrams and a planning certificate. Additional requirements depend on the property, including relevant strata and swimming-pool documents.

The NSW selling guide explains the principal attachments. Section 52A and the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2022 govern the statutory scheme; an inconsistent clause cannot simply exclude it. These protections are not a general guarantee that every building component is sound. Use current documents and notices: the Law Society’s contract guidance confirms changes to the prescribed cooling-off notice apply to exchanges from 1 June 2026.

What should you and the agent say when marketing the property?

Describe the property accurately and avoid assurances that cannot be supported. The agent has separate duties concerning misleading statements and prescribed material facts. An “as is” label should not contradict claims such as “fully renovated” or “council approved”. Check advertisements, photographs and answers to buyer enquiries against the documents you actually hold.

NSW Fair Trading explains agents’ obligations under section 52 of the Property and Stock Agents Act 2002, including disclosure of prescribed facts they know or ought reasonably to know. Silence or half-truths can also mislead. The ACCC’s real estate guidance addresses accurate property information.

Sections 18 and 30 of the Australian Consumer Law require conduct in trade or commerce. Their application to a private seller needs separate assessment; an agent’s commercial conduct is not automatically the seller’s. Other contractual and legal remedies may still matter. Refer uncertain questions about approval, boundaries or condition to your solicitor rather than guessing.

What does a real NSW case show about “as is” terms?

In 191 Bells Pty Ltd v WJ & HL Crittle Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 221, the NSW Court of Appeal dismissed a purchaser’s appeal concerning undisclosed contamination. The transaction included “as is” provisions and an agreed due-diligence process. The outcome depended on the actual terms, communications and evidence, rather than a universal disclosure rule.

The case concerned development land at Meroo Meadow and an option arrangement. Further investigations identified waste burial pits containing asbestos and other material. The purchaser alleged misleading conduct and argued that the agreement to assist its investigations required disclosure. The Court dismissed the appeal with costs.

The Court’s official summary explains that the assistance obligation did not require voluntary disclosure of every relevant matter, and the alleged positive misrepresentation was not established. This was a development transaction, not an ordinary house-defect damages award. Its practical lesson is to define responsibilities and assess the entire transaction. It does not make an “as is” clause immunity from false representations or mandatory statutory duties.

Can inspection reports reduce the risk of disputes?

Appropriate inspections can clarify condition, identify matters needing specialist advice and help parties negotiate before exchange. A seller’s report may assist, but buyers should consider their own independent advice. Neither an inspection nor a report automatically removes legal rights, proves every defect has been found or guarantees that the property complies with all laws.

The NSW inspection guide explains the limits of standard reports, including inaccessible areas and matters outside the inspector’s expertise. Repair estimates and specialist testing may require separate work. Discuss whether to commission a report, allow reasonable inspection access by arrangement and preserve complete reports with their dates and qualifications. Avoid presenting selected favourable extracts as an assessment of the whole property.

Do renovations or owner-builder work create extra obligations?

Recent building work can raise separate approval, insurance and statutory-warranty issues. Selling “as is” does not automatically remove those protections. An ordinary homeowner does not necessarily give a fresh building warranty merely by selling, but an owner-builder or developer may have additional responsibilities that require advice before the contract is issued.

NSW’s owner-builder guidance requires a consumer warning when land is sold within seven years and six months after the owner-builder permit was issued. The immediate next owner can also have statutory-warranty rights. Building Commission guidance explains that statutory warranties cannot be overridden by contract. Give your solicitor permits, approvals, contracts, completion dates and relevant insurance certificates so the applicable requirements can be checked.

Will an “as is” sale necessarily achieve a lower price?

There is no reliable universal percentage discount or fixed delay that applies to every “as is” sale. Buyers may allow for repair costs and uncertainty, but location, land value, demand and the intended use also influence offers. Compare the likely net outcome of selling now with completing carefully selected work first.

Obtain written repair quotes and ask the agent for comparable sales with similar condition and location. Allow for holding costs, marketing, insurance and possible delays. Separate cosmetic improvements from safety or compliance work requiring advice. If you agree to repairs during negotiations, record their scope, completion date and evidence required. Avoid promising to “fix everything” without an agreed specification and budget.

Can a buyer cancel or claim compensation after discovering a defect?

Discovering a defect does not automatically entitle a buyer to cancel or recover repair costs. The available remedy depends on the contract, disclosure requirements, representations, evidence and timing. Conversely, an “as is” clause does not defeat every claim. Obtain prompt legal advice if a buyer challenges the sale or threatens not to settle.

Under the vendor disclosure rules, missing prescribed documents can permit rescission within 14 days after contracting, provided settlement has not occurred. Prescribed-warranty rescission has different conditions and must generally occur before completion. A valid cancellation under that regime is distinct from a damages claim. Preserve the contract, advertisements, reports, correspondence and relevant photographs, and let your solicitor assess the notice and response deadlines.

How can you prepare for an “as is” sale?

Give your solicitor a complete account of the property before marketing begins. Identify what you will repair, what will remain in its current condition and any unresolved notices or disputes. Agree on accurate agent instructions and contract wording. Keep a written record of information supplied and any changes agreed with the buyer.

For strata property, provide relevant records about common-property problems and special levies. Confirm inclusions, tenancy arrangements and any promised work before exchange. CM Lawyers can assist with selling a property in NSW, preparing the contract and assessing disclosure issues. Contact Christine Manolakos and the team on (02) 9557 9000 or email lawyers@cmlaw.com.au.

This article provides general information about selling property in NSW. It is not a substitute for legal advice about the property, contract, disclosures or circumstances of a particular sale.

Key resources

CM Lawyers  ·  Level 3, Unit 3.07, 18–30 Faversham Street, Marrickville NSW 2204  ·  (02) 9557 9000  ·  lawyers@cmlaw.com.au