Updated 3 November 2026
Contract for Sales - Seller’s Most Asked Questions #41. How do I deal with lowball offers?
How should you respond to a lowball property offer?
Assess a low offer against reliable market evidence and the buyer’s complete terms before deciding whether to reject it, counteroffer or negotiate. NSW sellers generally do not have to accept an offer or make a counteroffer. A calm response, clear instructions and legal review help protect your position during negotiations.
Ask your agent to confirm the price, conditions and proposed settlement date. An offer below your expectations may open a useful discussion, but negotiating does not guarantee an improved price. Decide what outcome works for you before responding.
What makes an offer a lowball offer?
Lowball is an informal description, not a legal category with a fixed percentage threshold. An offer substantially below the asking price may still reflect comparable sales, defects or current demand. The asking price, the agent’s estimated selling price and a buyer’s offer are different figures with different purposes.
Under NSW pricing guidance, an agent’s estimate must be reasonable and supported by evidence. Request recent comparable sales and an explanation of differences in location, land size, condition and features. Asking prices on unsold listings are not proof of achieved sale prices.
Must you accept the highest offer or make a counteroffer?
A private seller is generally free to reject an offer and is not ordinarily required to accept the highest price. Conditions, settlement timing and confidence that the buyer can complete may justify choosing another proposal. Refusing to counteroffer does not, by itself, create a legal obligation to compensate the buyer.
NSW Government guidance recognises that sellers may choose a lower offer. This freedom is different once a binding contract exists. Check any option, existing contract or special legal obligations before assuming you can sell to someone else.
What should you compare besides the purchase price?
Compare the whole offer, including its conditions and the practical steps needed to complete the sale. A higher price may carry greater uncertainty if finance, another property sale or extensive inspections remain unresolved. A lower offer may suit your circumstances, but a cash buyer’s description alone does not guarantee completion.
- Finance and conditions: identify what must happen, by when, and any proposed right to withdraw.
- Deposit and settlement: check amounts, payment timing and whether the completion date suits your plans.
- Inclusions and repairs: identify requests that change the effective price or require additional work.
How can you make a useful counteroffer?
Give your agent clear written instructions about the price and terms you would consider, supported by your reasons. You can negotiate settlement timing, inclusions or other practical terms as well as price. Keep the proposal subject to your solicitor’s or conveyancer’s review and the intended contract process before committing.
Avoid negotiating one term in isolation. A concession on price may be acceptable if another term improves, but your lawyer should check how any condition operates. Set a realistic response deadline and record what was communicated; silence should not be treated as acceptance.
Can competing offers help you negotiate?
Genuine competing offers may inform negotiations, but any statement about them must be accurate. General interest, an inspection booking and a firm offer are different things. Do not invent another buyer, exaggerate an offer or create false urgency to pressure someone into increasing their price or abandoning conditions.
The ACCC’s real estate guidance warns against misleading buyers to obtain higher offers. Ask the agent to explain what can properly be communicated while respecting confidentiality. A request for best and final offers should use a clear, honest process.
Must your agent tell you about every low offer?
As at 3 November 2026, an agent must communicate purchase offers as soon as practicable until exchange, unless the seller has given contrary written instructions. This can include instructions about offers below a specified amount.
The Property and Stock Agents Regulation sets out further rules about how agents handle offers. Review any minimum-price instruction as your circumstances change, particularly when the November reforms begin.
How do the November 2026 pricing changes affect negotiations?
New NSW pricing and underquoting rules begin on 17 November 2026. They have been announced but are not yet operating on this article’s update date. Written offers rejected solely because the price is too low will affect permitted advertised prices, making accurate records of rejection reasons particularly important.
For agency agreements entered from that date, or earlier agreements whose estimated price is revised from that date, agents must report an offer requiring estimate revision despite contrary seller instructions. Separate advertising rules have their own transitional requirements. Statement of Information requirements begin on 8 February 2027.
Check the official reform guidance for your campaign. An offer below asking price is not itself underquoting; agents must comply with the applicable pricing and advertising obligations.
When does an accepted offer become binding?
In an ordinary NSW private-treaty sale, the parties generally become bound when contracts are exchanged. Agreeing on price is usually one step towards that outcome. However, electronic documents, the language used and an agent’s authority can matter, so obtain advice before assuming that a message or signature has no legal effect.
Confirm who is authorised to exchange and have agreed terms incorporated correctly. Under NSW exchange guidance, sellers have no statutory cooling-off period after exchange. The buyer’s position depends on the transaction and any valid waiver; a seller cannot simply withdraw because a better offer arrives.
How should you weigh a lower offer against waiting?
Compare the likely net proceeds and practical risks of accepting now with the cost of keeping the property on the market. Relevant costs may include interest, insurance, maintenance, rates and additional marketing. Future offers and market movements are uncertain, so holding out for the asking price is not a guaranteed strategy.
Ask for an updated market assessment and calculate costs using your actual figures. Include moving arrangements and any linked purchase. Your agent can advise on marketing; your lawyer should assess contract risk. Neither an appraisal nor an optimistic forecast guarantees the eventual result.
What does a real NSW case show about competing offers?
In Borzi Smythe Pty Ltd v Campbell Holdings (NSW) Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 233, negotiations involved a false report of a competing offer for a Kangaroo Valley property. The case illustrates how the source, wording and context of statements, together with proof of loss, can affect a claim against an agent.
The seller’s son told the agent another buyer had offered $900,000 when that was untrue. The purchasing company paid $920,000 and later sued the agency. The NSW Court of Appeal dismissed its appeal with costs. On the particular evidence, the agent had attributed and relayed the information without adopting its truth; the communications were between experienced agents. The purchaser also failed to prove its claimed loss.
No claim had been brought against the seller’s son. The decision does not authorise invented offers or mean attribution always avoids liability. It concerns representations during negotiations, not a duty to make counteroffers.
What if you disagree with your agent’s advice?
Request the reasoning behind the agent’s recommendation and keep copies of offers, advice and your instructions. A disappointing price or missed negotiation does not automatically establish negligence or recoverable loss. A claim requires a legal basis and evidence connecting the conduct to loss, so obtain advice before threatening proceedings.
Raise concerns with the agency principal and consider NSW Fair Trading’s complaint service. Before replacing the agent, review the agency agreement, termination notice and continuing commission exposure. A later sale to an introduced buyer may still generate commission; appointing another agent can create competing claims.
What should you do before agreeing to the final terms?
Confirm the complete proposal in writing and have your solicitor or conveyancer check the contract before authorising exchange. Your decision should reflect price, conditions, completion risk and your circumstances. Keep a record of the agreed terms and any rejected offers so that instructions and marketing information remain accurate.
CM Lawyers assists NSW property sellers with contract preparation, amendments and settlement. Contact Christine Manolakos and the team to review the legal implications of a proposed offer, including conditions or concessions that may affect your final proceeds.
General information only, current at 3 November 2026. Have a lawyer check your agency agreement, sale contract and circumstances before relying on this guide.
Key resources
NSW guidance on making an offer — seller choice and the communication of purchase offers.
NSW price estimation and underquoting guidance — evidence supporting a reasonable selling-price estimate.
Property and Stock Agents Regulation 2022 — agents’ conduct and offer-reporting requirements.
NSW property-agent law changes — the November 2026 reforms and staged commencement dates.
ACCC guidance for real estate — misleading statements about prices and competing offers.
NSW guidance on sales contracts and exchange — exchange authority and cooling-off distinctions.
NSW guidance on agency agreements — commission, fees, termination and continuing obligations.
NSW Fair Trading property complaints — help with disputes involving real estate professionals.
Borzi Smythe v Campbell Holdings [2008] NSWCA 233 — judgment concerning competing-offer representations.
