Updated 1 November 2026
Contract for Sales - Seller’s Most Asked Questions #33: How do I handle repairs requested by buyers?
How should NSW sellers handle buyer repair requests?
Ask for the buyer’s concerns in writing, obtain reliable evidence and have your solicitor check the contract before promising repairs. The response depends on whether contracts have been exchanged, what obligations already exist and whether the issue involves an existing defect, an agreed repair or new damage before settlement.
- Separate urgent safety concerns from maintenance, cosmetic preferences and proposed upgrades.
- Compare the cost and timing of repairs with a negotiated price adjustment.
- Record any agreement precisely, including access, completion evidence and the effect on settlement.
Must a seller fix every defect identified by a buyer?
A building report does not automatically require a NSW seller to repair every defect it identifies. Obligations depend on the contract and applicable law, including any repair promises, disclosure requirements and statutory protections. Equally, describing a property as being sold in its present condition does not excuse misleading conduct.
Tell your solicitor about known defects, unapproved work, notices and previous assurances. Ask which matters require disclosure or action. Agents have separate obligations concerning misleading statements and prescribed material facts. Avoid broad assurances such as saying that a roof has never leaked unless you can substantiate them.
What changes once contracts have been exchanged?
Before exchange, buyers can usually negotiate repairs or a different price as part of their offer. After exchange, the parties’ rights depend on the binding contract and any applicable statutory rights. A buyer’s request alone does not change the price, extend settlement or create a right to cancel.
Check any inspection condition and its deadlines promptly. Cooling-off rights, where available, are separate from a repair entitlement. The Law Society’s buying guidance explains why contract review matters. Have your solicitor assess existing obligations before accepting, rejecting or modifying a demand made through the agent.
How should building and pest reports be assessed?
Read the actual inspection report rather than relying on a verbal description of its findings. Identify the defect, its likely cause, inspection limitations and recommended further investigations. Obtain an appropriate specialist assessment where necessary, particularly for structural movement, roof leaks, electrical hazards, plumbing problems or evidence of timber pests.
Building and pest inspections have different scopes, and inaccessible areas may remain unassessed. Ask for photographs and itemised quotations. A recommendation to investigate is not proof that complete replacement is necessary. Address immediate hazards appropriately while obtaining advice about responsibility for permanent work.
Should the seller repair the problem or negotiate an allowance?
Choose the response by comparing the verified problem, available time, likely cost and parties’ priorities. Completing defined repairs may reassure a buyer, while a negotiated allowance can avoid rushed work. A retention may help settlement proceed, but its legal basis, amount, control and release conditions require careful attention.
| Option | When it may help | What to settle first |
|---|---|---|
| Seller completes repairs | The work is defined and can be completed properly before settlement. | Scope, contractor, approvals, deadline and evidence of completion. |
| Price adjustment or allowance | The buyer prefers to arrange the work after settlement. | Amount, settlement treatment and precisely which repair claims are resolved. |
| Retention of funds | Settlement can proceed while an identified issue remains unresolved. | Contractual basis or written agreement, stakeholder, release triggers and dispute process. |
What should a written repair agreement include?
A repair agreement should identify exactly what must be done, who will do it, the completion deadline and how satisfactory completion will be assessed. Your solicitor should incorporate enforceable terms into the contract or an appropriate variation. An informal assurance that everything will be fixed leaves too much uncertain.
- Specify the defect, location, scope, materials and any required approvals.
- Set access arrangements, notice requirements and responsibility for damage during work.
- Require relevant invoices, certificates, warranties and inspection evidence.
- Explain incomplete-work remedies, dispute resolution and whether settlement must still proceed.
- For retained funds, identify the stakeholder, release evidence and dispute procedure.
Who should carry out agreed repairs?
Use contractors with the qualifications, licences and insurance appropriate to the work. Electrical, plumbing, drainage and gas work requires relevant licensing regardless of price. Other residential building work generally requires a contractor licence when its value exceeds $5,000 including GST. Check the licence category as well as the contractor’s identity.
Use the NSW contractor checks before engagement. Home building compensation insurance generally applies to residential building work over $20,000 including GST, subject to exemptions. Check requirements before paying or starting, and retain contracts, receipts and compliance documents for the buyer.
What if the repair concerns a strata property?
Check whether the affected item belongs to the individual lot or forms part of common property before promising repairs. The owners corporation generally maintains common property, but the strata plan and by-laws can affect responsibility. A seller should not promise work that requires another party’s approval without resolving that issue.
Review strata repair responsibilities, meeting records, existing reports and proposed levies with your solicitor. Obtain written information from the strata manager about approved work and timing. A promise that the owners corporation will repair a roof next month should not rest on an informal conversation.
Can final inspection issues justify delaying settlement?
A final inspection helps the buyer check the property against the contract and agreed obligations. It does not automatically reopen negotiations over every pre-existing defect. Whether an unresolved issue permits a claim, retention, delay or termination depends on the contract and law, so obtain advice before changing settlement instructions.
The 2026 standard contract addresses fair wear and tear and includes procedures for certain claims and retained funds. Special conditions can alter those provisions. Neither side should assume that a buyer can deduct a preferred repair estimate or that every retention requires a new agreement.
What if the property suffers new damage before settlement?
New damage between exchange and settlement raises different issues from defects that already existed. In NSW, risk generally remains with the seller until completion, although earlier possession arrangements can matter. Statutory provisions may allow a price adjustment or, for substantial damage, rescission, subject to the applicable requirements and deadlines.
Notify your solicitor and insurer promptly, preserve photographs and take appropriate steps to prevent further damage. Sections 66K–66M of the Conveyancing Act 1919 require specific assessment. A storm-damaged roof should not simply be treated as another optional cosmetic request.
What does Blecher v Zou show about repair disputes?
In Blecher v Zou [2024] NSWSC 70, the NSW Supreme Court considered a written repair agreement following a pre-settlement dispute. The decision shows why the agreed scope, reasonable cooperation and release conditions matter. A repair commitment does not necessarily require an upgrade or allow the buyer to retain all funds indefinitely.
The Dover Heights transaction settled with $100,000 retained while specified repairs were arranged. Disagreement continued over the garage roof and a pool light. The court rejected the demand for wholesale roof replacement and found that the buyers had not reasonably cooperated with repair investigations. It declared that $99,692 belonged to the seller and $308 to the buyers.
The outcome depended on the particular agreement and evidence. It is not a general entitlement to withhold settlement money or a rule that sellers can disregard agreed repairs.
How can sellers resolve disagreements without escalating costs?
Keep negotiations focused on evidence, contractual rights and a workable solution. Ask the buyer to identify the disputed work and supporting report, then respond through the agreed representatives. If opinions differ, consider an appropriately qualified independent expert and a documented resolution process before spending more on a dispute than necessary.
Flexibility about timing, access or a reasonable allowance may preserve the transaction. It should not mean accepting an unlimited obligation. Confirm revised terms through your solicitor and avoid withdrawing an existing commitment merely because the negotiations have become frustrating.
What should the seller check before agreeing to a solution?
Before accepting a repair proposal, confirm the legal obligation, reliable cost estimate, contractor availability and realistic completion date. Check how the arrangement affects settlement, retained funds and any related purchase. A lawyer should review the final wording so commercial flexibility produces clear responsibilities rather than another unresolved dispute.
Keep one complete record of reports, quotations, correspondence and completed work. Christine Manolakos at CM Lawyers can advise on the sale contract, negotiate repair terms and help assess a buyer’s claim before you commit to work or change settlement arrangements.
General information only, current at 1 November 2026. Have a lawyer check your sale contract, repair obligations and proposed variations before acting.
Key resources
Law Society: 2026 sale contract sample — standard provisions; check the actual contract and amendments.
NSW Government: inspection reports — building and pest inspections and their limitations.
NSW Government: misrepresentation — agents’ statements and material fact obligations.
NSW Government: contractor checks — qualifications and appropriate licence categories.
SIRA: home building compensation — insurance requirements and exemptions for building work.
NSW Government: strata repairs — lot owner and owners corporation responsibilities.
Conveyancing Act 1919, Part 4 Division 7 — risk and damage before completion.
Law Society: deciding to buy — contract review, conditions and pre-purchase enquiries.
Blecher v Zou [2024] NSWSC 70 — judgment on repairs and retained settlement funds.
CM Lawyers — Selling a property — contract preparation and conveyancing for NSW sellers.
