Updated 31 October 2026
CM Law’s Ultimate 50 Things You Need to Know About Property Settlement During Divorce #3. What happens if we cannot agree on the property division?
What happens if we cannot agree on property division?
If you cannot agree on property division, you can negotiate through lawyers, use suitable dispute resolution or ask the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia to decide. Court proceedings do not prevent later settlement. The outcome depends on the evidence and legal criteria, with no automatic rule that everything is divided equally.
For married couples and eligible de facto couples in NSW, the Family Law Act 1975 governs property adjustment. Divorce and property settlement are separate processes. Start by identifying the disagreement: missing disclosure, disputed values, competing percentages or difficulty funding a payout may each require a different response.
Must we attend mediation before applying to court?
Prospective parties generally must take genuine steps to resolve a property dispute before filing, but exemptions apply. Mediation is one option within the pre-action process, not an absolute requirement in every case. Family violence, urgency or undue prejudice may justify an exemption, and nobody should continue an unsafe dispute-resolution process.
The pre-action procedures address exchanging information, attempting appropriate dispute resolution and giving written notice of a proposed application. A mediator helps negotiate but does not impose a decision. Lawyer-assisted negotiations or other suitable processes may narrow the issues.
A section 60I certificate concerns parenting applications; it is not a requirement for a property-only application. Your lawyer should assess the applicable steps and any exemption before filing.
What financial information must each person disclose?
Both parties must give full and frank disclosure of relevant financial circumstances, including assets, liabilities, income and financial resources. This duty begins before court proceedings and continues until the matter is resolved. Disclosure is not limited to jointly owned property or documents the other person already knows exist or specifically requests.
Useful records commonly include:
- Bank and loan statements, tax returns and evidence of income.
- Property records, superannuation statements and investment accounts.
- Relevant business, company and trust records, and explanations of significant transfers.
Keep information current under the disclosure duty. Where values are disputed, an agreed single expert may help. Suspected missing assets should be investigated through lawful disclosure requests and, where justified, court processes. Guessing a property pool makes informed negotiation difficult.
What time limits apply to a property application?
For married couples, a property application generally must be filed within twelve months after the divorce becomes final. For de facto couples, the usual deadline is two years after the relationship breaks down. You can seek property orders before divorce, and ongoing negotiations do not automatically extend the relevant filing deadline.
The Court’s property overview explains these limits and de facto eligibility requirements. If time has expired, leave may be necessary and is not guaranteed. A lawyer should check the relevant dates, eligibility and any existing financial agreement promptly. Do not wait for informal discussions to conclude when a deadline is approaching.
How does a contested property case progress?
A contested case begins with an application identifying the orders sought and the required supporting documents. The Court then manages disclosure, evidence, disputed values and opportunities for settlement. The first court event usually concerns case management rather than a final division of property, and the pathway depends on the issues involved.
The Court’s filing guidance identifies documents such as the Initiating Application, Financial Statement, Genuine Steps Certificate and Undertaking as to Disclosure. An affidavit or Financial Questionnaire may also be required, depending on the application. Documents must be properly served.
Typical stages include:
Directions about documents, valuations and any interim issues.
Appropriate dispute resolution, such as a conciliation conference or private mediation.
Preparation for a final hearing if material issues remain unresolved.
Some matters follow a streamlined pathway. Your lawyer should check the current financial proceedings practice direction and the orders made in your case.
Can the Court protect property while negotiations continue?
Urgent or interim orders may be available where assets are at risk, immediate financial issues need attention or waiting for final determination would cause serious difficulty. The Court requires evidence supporting the particular orders sought. Urgency must be explained; requesting an early hearing does not guarantee that an injunction will be granted.
If there is evidence of a proposed disposal or transfer that could defeat a claim, seek advice promptly about preservation orders. Keep transaction records and relevant correspondence. The urgent application guidance explains supporting affidavit and urgency requirements. Avoid retaliatory withdrawals or asset transfers that could worsen the dispute.
How does the Court decide a fair property division?
The Court considers existing property interests and liabilities, each party’s contributions, and their current and future circumstances. It must be satisfied that making property orders is just and equitable. Financial contributions are relevant, but so are non-financial contributions, homemaking and parenting. There is no automatic fifty-fifty starting entitlement or fixed settlement formula.
Under the framework clarified in June 2025, relevant considerations include:
- Contributions before, during and after the relationship.
- Age, health, income, earning capacity and care of children, including housing needs.
- Where relevant, family violence affecting contributions and its economic effect on current and future circumstances.
Liabilities and material intentional or reckless wastage may also matter. Orders can provide for transfers, sales, payments and superannuation splitting. A party wishing to retain the home should investigate refinancing and a workable payout rather than assume retention is affordable.
What does Stanford v Stanford explain about property orders?
Stanford v Stanford shows why a court must identify existing property interests and consider whether changing them is just and equitable. The High Court rejected an assumption that property necessarily had to be redistributed. Its unusual facts concerned spouses living apart because of illness, so the decision does not predict an ordinary separation settlement.
In Stanford v Stanford [2012] HCA 52, the wife required residential care while the husband remained at home and continued providing for her needs. Proceedings began through her case guardian and continued through her legal personal representatives after her death.
The High Court allowed the husband’s appeal and dismissed the property application because a just and equitable basis for the proposed adjustment had not been established. The practical lesson is to address the legal criteria with evidence. Disagreement alone does not determine either person’s percentage, and the current statutory framework must be applied to each case.
How much will proceedings cost, and how long will they take?
The cost and duration of a property case depend on its complexity, disclosure, expert evidence, interim disputes and when agreement becomes possible. No reliable fixed estimate applies to every couple. Each party generally pays their own legal costs, although the Court can make a costs order where the circumstances justify it.
Legal Aid NSW explains the general costs position. Ask for staged estimates covering legal work, filing fees, valuations and other disbursements. Review the remaining dispute against likely further costs. Unreasonable non-compliance or litigation conduct may have costs consequences, but a more favourable property result does not automatically mean the other person pays your lawyer.
Can we settle after court proceedings have started?
You can reach agreement while a property case is underway. A negotiated resolution can address all issues or narrow what remains for the Court to decide. The terms should identify assets, debts, payment dates and implementation steps clearly, and each person should receive advice before accepting obligations that may be difficult to perform.
Consent orders require court approval and must be just and equitable. A financial agreement is a different legal mechanism with specific requirements, including independent legal advice. An informal agreement does not provide the same finality.
Check refinancing, releases from joint borrowing, tax implications and any required superannuation trustee notification. Allocating a debt between former partners does not, by itself, release someone from their lender’s contract.
What if the other person does not comply with property orders?
Property orders bind the people subject to them, and non-compliance may require an enforcement application. The appropriate remedy depends on the obligation breached, such as paying money, transferring property or signing documents. Keep the orders and evidence of missed obligations, and obtain advice before choosing an enforcement process or taking unilateral action.
The Court’s National Enforcement List, operating from 21 September 2026, covers specified enforcement applications in financial or property-only matters. It does not cover contempt or contravention applications. Depending on the circumstances, the Court may make orders to recover money or authorise someone to sign a deed or instrument, such as a property transfer, when a party fails to sign as required by an order.
CM Lawyers can advise on negotiation, disclosure, proceedings and implementing a settlement. Contact Christine Manolakos with your financial records, important dates and any existing agreements or orders so the next step can be assessed.
General information, not advice about your circumstances. Have a family lawyer check the applicable law, deadlines, proposed agreements and court documents before you act.
Key resources
Family Law Act 1975 — property adjustment, disclosure, costs and enforcement powers.
FCFCOA: when you cannot agree — applications, required documents and available pathways.
FCFCOA pre-action procedures — genuine steps, dispute resolution and exemptions.
FCFCOA duty of disclosure — financial information and continuing obligations.
FCFCOA property overview — time limits and de facto eligibility.
Attorney-General’s Department: June 2025 family-law changes — the property framework and relevant effects of family violence.
Stanford v Stanford [2012] HCA 52 — High Court reasons on just and equitable property orders.
FCFCOA: formalising an agreement — consent orders and financial agreements.
FCFCOA National Enforcement List — the current procedure for covered financial and property enforcement matters.
