Skip to main content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Updated 4 November 2026

CM Law's Ultimate List: Things You Need to Know About Child Custody #48: What is split custody?

Siblings sometimes need different living arrangements after separation. The starting point is each child’s best interests, including safety, individual needs and sibling relationships. A workable proposal should explain why living apart is appropriate and how the children can maintain safe connections, without treating children as assets to divide between parents.

What does “split custody” mean in NSW?

“Split custody” informally describes siblings living primarily in different households, such as one child with each parent. It is not a separate category of order under Australian family law. Modern legal language focuses on parenting arrangements: where children live, who they spend time with and responsibility for decisions about them.

Family Relationships Online explains the current terminology. Ordinary parenting disputes in NSW generally proceed under the federal Family Law Act in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA). An arrangement does not become appropriate simply because it gives each parent the same number of children.

Must siblings always live together?

There is no automatic rule that siblings must always live together or apart. Their relationship is an important part of assessing each child’s best interests. Different arrangements need to be considered individually, including the effect of separation on the siblings and whether ongoing contact can occur safely and practically.

The government’s parenting-plan guidance identifies siblings among significant relationships. Examine the actual relationship, support the children provide each other and any relevant risks. Avoid presenting separation as a punishment, bargaining tool or guaranteed solution to conflict. A label such as “last resort” does not replace the statutory assessment.

What factors does the court consider for each child?

The court considers safety, the child’s views and developmental, psychological, emotional and cultural needs. It also considers caregivers’ capacity to meet those needs, the benefit of safe relationships with parents and other significant people, and other relevant circumstances. Different children in the same family may need different arrangements.

The Court’s children overview explains this framework, including additional cultural considerations for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children. Identify concrete needs, such as schooling, disability support or protection from violence. A parent’s convenience, a child’s gender or an assumed entitlement to equal time cannot determine the outcome.

Can a child choose which parent to live with?

There is no fixed age at which a child automatically decides the parenting arrangement. Their views matter, but must be understood in context, including maturity, understanding and any pressure they may face. A strongly expressed preference does not remove the need to assess safety, relationships and the child’s other needs.

Legal Aid NSW explains how views are considered. Listen without asking children to choose sides, rehearse answers or carry proposals between parents. Children cannot be compelled to express views. Ask your lawyer about an appropriate process for hearing them, rather than treating a private conversation as a binding decision.

How can siblings maintain their relationship while living apart?

Build safe sibling contact into the proposal, rather than leaving it to chance. Depending on the children’s needs, this could include overlapping weekends, shared activities, holiday time or telephone and video calls. Specify transport, timing and adult responsibilities, while allowing for school commitments, distance and the children’s changing circumstances.

Our practical recommendation is to test the timetable against an ordinary school week and school holidays. Consider whether travel is realistic and whether contact needs safeguards. Avoid promising unrestricted time together where safety concerns require professional assessment. Keeping a relationship meaningful does not necessarily require identical schedules for every child.

What evidence can help assess different living arrangements?

Useful evidence explains each child’s actual needs and how the proposed arrangement would meet them. Relevant material may include care histories, school information, medical evidence and details of safety concerns. Focus on specific events and practical arrangements, rather than unsupported claims that one parent is generally better or more deserving.

A court-ordered Family Report can assess relationships, needs, views and risks. Its recommendations assist the judge but do not decide the case. The assessment is not confidential counselling; information may become evidence. Prepare honestly and avoid coaching children or asking professionals to support conclusions beyond their expertise.

Can parents agree without a contested court hearing?

Yes. Parents can agree on suitable arrangements and record them in a parenting plan or seek consent orders. A parenting plan is a voluntary written, signed and dated agreement; it is not enforceable like a court order. Consent orders become binding once approved by the court, which considers the children’s best interests.

The Court’s agreement guidance explains these options. Address each child’s residence, time with both parents, sibling contact, holidays and major decisions. Obtain advice if orders already exist: a later parenting plan can affect their operation. Do not assume an informal variation has safely resolved every legal obligation.

Is mediation required before applying for parenting orders?

A section 60I certificate from a family dispute resolution practitioner is generally required before starting contested parenting proceedings, unless an exemption applies. Family violence, child abuse, urgency or inability to participate effectively may justify an exemption. Seeking consent orders does not ordinarily require this certificate. Safety should guide the process.

The Court’s family dispute resolution guidance explains the requirements. A certificate can record that mediation was unsuitable; it does not always mean both parents attended. Tell your lawyer or practitioner about risks early. Do not delay urgent advice while trying to arrange a joint meeting that may be unsafe.

What does a real NSW case show about siblings living apart?

In Haughton & Brickley (No 2) [2024] FedCFamC2F 1721, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia at Newcastle made different living arrangements for three siblings. The decision illustrates the importance of addressing each child’s safety and needs while considering how their sibling relationships can continue in the particular circumstances.

On 3 December 2024, Judge Betts ordered the older child to live with his father, by consent, and the twin sisters with their mother. Serious safeguarding concerns shaped the orders, which provided scheduled telephone or video communication between the siblings.

The decision is not a general endorsement of dividing siblings between parents. Although delivered in December 2024, it applied the parenting law before the May 2024 reforms because the final hearing had already commenced. New parenting proceedings are assessed under the updated statutory framework.

Does a child’s main home determine who makes major decisions?

No. Living arrangements and parental responsibility are distinct. Each parent ordinarily has parental responsibility, subject to court orders. Orders can allocate joint or sole decision-making for some or all major long-term issues, such as education or health. Read the actual orders before assuming residence gives exclusive authority over those decisions.

The Attorney-General’s Department explains the changes commencing on 6 May 2024, including removal of the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility. That change did not create an entitlement to equal time or to divide siblings equally. Ensure any proposal separately addresses care schedules and responsibility for important decisions.

How does living apart affect child support and costs?

Having one child live with each parent does not automatically cancel child support. The assessment considers income, the children’s ages and care arrangements for each child. Where both parents are assessed to pay support to each other, the amounts are offset to determine the net payment. Obtain an assessment for your circumstances.

Services Australia’s formula explains the calculation. Report changes in care promptly and keep accurate records. Separately, prepare a realistic budget for travel, school expenses and items needed in each home. Parenting arrangements do not automatically require selling a family asset; property division involves separate legal questions.

Can arrangements change as children’s needs develop?

Arrangements may need review when needs, risks or circumstances change, but existing orders should not simply be ignored. Reconsidering final parenting orders is governed by section 65DAAA of the Family Law Act. The court must consider whether circumstances have changed significantly and be satisfied that reconsideration is in the child’s best interests.

The Act also provides a route where all parties agree to reconsideration. Obtain advice on the appropriate process, including consent orders or any proposed parenting plan. The 2024 reforms did not automatically cancel existing orders. Seek urgent legal help if new safety concerns make the current arrangement problematic.

What should parents do before proposing sibling separation?

Prepare a proposal that addresses each child individually and explains the effect on their sibling relationship. Identify safety concerns, care needs, schooling, transport, communication and decision-making responsibilities. Consider alternatives and obtain advice before changing an existing arrangement. A practical plan should be workable for the children throughout ordinary weeks and holidays.

For advice about parenting arrangements in NSW, contact Christine Manolakos and CM Lawyers on (02) 9557 9000 or email lawyers@cmlaw.com.au.

This article provides general information about family law and is not a substitute for legal advice about your circumstances.

Key resources

CM Lawyers  ·  Level 3, Unit 3.07, 18–30 Faversham Street, Marrickville NSW 2204  ·  (02) 9557 9000  ·  lawyers@cmlaw.com.au