Skip to main content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Updated 25 October 2026

CM Law’s Ultimate 50 Things You Need to Know About Property Settlement During Divorce #7. Can we settle our property matters without going to court?

Yes, separating couples in NSW can resolve their property and financial arrangements without a contested court hearing. Negotiation and mediation can help you agree on a division, which can then be formalised through consent orders or an appropriate financial agreement. Consent orders still involve court approval, although attendance is usually unnecessary.

My focus is on reaching a workable outcome while preserving as much of the property pool as possible. That requires sound advice, reliable financial information and clear documents. A rushed agreement that leaves important issues unresolved can create further expense rather than bring the dispute to an end.

1. Christine on what settlement statistics actually show

Legal Aid NSW’s 2024–25 Annual Report records 3,157 family dispute resolution conferences, with agreements reached in 2,296 conferences, a 72.7% agreement rate. Its performance measure includes partial or full settlement. The service covers different family disputes, including parenting, adoption and property matters.

These are Legal Aid NSW figures, not CM Lawyers’ results or a settlement rate for every NSW property dispute. My practical reading is that structured dispute resolution deserves serious consideration where it is safe and suitable. Even a partial agreement can leave fewer issues to argue about. The figures cannot guarantee that a particular negotiation will succeed or that mediation will resolve everything in one day.

2. Civil procedure encourages just quick and cheap resolution

Section 56 of the NSW Civil Procedure Act 2005 identifies the “just, quick and cheap resolution of the real issues” as the overriding purpose of civil procedure. The Judicial Commission’s civil case management guidance also explains the importance of keeping costs proportionate to the significance and complexity of the dispute.

Family property proceedings operate under their own federal framework. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia’s Central Practice Direction similarly emphasises lawful, just resolution with unnecessary cost and delay avoided, while prioritising safety. Parties and lawyers should identify what genuinely requires a decision, exchange relevant information and consider efficient ways to resolve it.

For me, the practical question is whether the next legal step will materially improve the client’s position. Repeating the same argument in another letter may achieve less than obtaining a missing valuation or making a realistic offer. Efficiency requires preparation and judgment about which issues matter.

3. Criminal procedure has different limits

Criminal cases can also resolve without a contested trial through appropriate charge negotiations and guilty pleas. However, the NSW prosecution guidelines require charge resolution to serve the public interest and reflect the criminal conduct that can be proved. Victims’ views must be considered, but they do not control the prosecution’s decision. The court determines any sentence.

A private property settlement does not cancel criminal charges or change an apprehended domestic violence order. Where separation involves allegations of violence, the financial dispute and criminal proceedings require coordinated advice about their different procedures. A person should never be pressured to accept an adverse property outcome in exchange for a supposed promise that a prosecution will disappear.

4. Choose a suitable way to resolve the property dispute

Negotiation can begin through solicitors exchanging financial information and proposals. Mediation provides an independent person to help the parties explore agreement; the mediator does not impose a result. Depending on safety and practical needs, discussions may occur in separate rooms or remotely. Collaborative practice is another option for parties who agree to that structured process.

Arbitration is different: an independent arbitrator considers evidence and arguments and determines the financial dispute. It can provide an alternative to a contested court hearing, but the parties must understand the procedure, costs and legal effect of the award. There is no requirement to try every available process in sequence.

Before commencing contested property proceedings, the pre-action procedures generally require genuine attempts at resolution and relevant disclosure, unless an exemption applies. Urgency, family violence or a risk of prejudice can justify a different approach. Continuing negotiations after proceedings begin may still narrow or resolve the case.

5. Reliable disclosure makes informed negotiation possible

Prepare a clear schedule of assets, debts and financial resources, supported by bank statements, tax records, superannuation information and appropriate valuations. Include businesses, trusts and overseas interests where relevant. A proposal based on an incomplete understanding of ownership or liabilities may be impossible to implement or substantially disadvantage one party.

The property reforms commencing on 10 June 2025 placed financial disclosure duties in the Family Law Act and expressly address relevant economic effects of family violence. Negotiations should consider contributions and current and future circumstances, as well as the property pool. There is no automatic rule that every separation produces an equal division.

The statutory disclosure duty applies to financial proceedings and preparation for them. A financial agreement has its own legal requirements, and material non-disclosure can expose it to challenge. Whichever approach is chosen, accurate information is essential to informed advice and a sustainable settlement.

Consent orders are proposed orders submitted to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. A registrar usually considers the application without the parties attending. Approval is not automatic: financial orders must be just and equitable. Once made, they are binding court orders, with only limited grounds for later alteration.

A binding financial agreement does not require court approval, but must satisfy technical statutory requirements. Each party needs independent legal advice on the prescribed matters before signing. A signed homemade agreement or an exchange of emails does not, by itself, provide the same finality as compliant financial arrangements under the Family Law Act.

The document should explain who receives each asset, how debts will be discharged, when transfers or payments occur and what happens if a required step fails. Check refinance capacity and lender requirements before promising a transfer of the home. Superannuation splitting also requires specific drafting and attention to the fund trustee’s procedural rights.

7. A real decision shows why pressure undermines finality

In Thorne v Kennedy, decided by the High Court in 2017, financial agreements signed before and shortly after marriage were set aside for unconscionable conduct; a majority also found undue influence. The woman had received independent legal advice but signed in circumstances involving substantial pressure and disadvantage.

This was not an ordinary negotiated settlement after separation. Its relevance is that a signature and legal advice do not cure every problem in how an agreement was obtained. Allowing time for informed advice and a genuine decision is part of achieving an effective resolution.

8. Keep the process focused and protect deadlines

Ask your solicitor for advice on a realistic range of outcomes and the likely work needed to resolve the remaining disagreement. Compare an offer with the costs, uncertainty and delay of pursuing a different result. Consider whether an agreed independent valuation could remove an argument that otherwise generates repeated correspondence and competing reports.

A staged cost estimate helps you decide how much to spend on advice, valuation evidence, mediation preparation and any later hearing. Ask what is included and when the estimate will be reviewed. This makes the cost of the next decision visible before you authorise it.

Set practical dates for disclosure, proposals and any mediation, then review progress. A suitable agreement may resolve quickly; contested valuations, non-disclosure or complex ownership can take longer. If assets are being dissipated or safety is at risk, urgent court protection may be necessary. Seeking proportionate resolution does not require accepting an unsafe or uninformed bargain.

Property applications ordinarily need to be brought within 12 months after a divorce takes effect, or within two years after a de facto relationship ends. Negotiations do not stop those time limits. Obtain advice before a deadline approaches, including about any required permission to apply late.

For advice on negotiating and formalising your property settlement, contact CM Lawyers’ family law team. We can help identify the issues, assess the available process and document a workable outcome. This article is general information; advice should address your circumstances and any related proceedings.

Key resources

CM Lawyers  ·  Level 3, Unit 3.07, 18–30 Faversham Street, Marrickville NSW 2204  ·  (02) 9557 9000  ·  lawyers@cmlaw.com.au